WATERTOWN, N.Y. — The latest property transactions in the city of Watertown filed at the Jefferson County clerk’s office in December 2023:
Looking to buy or sell property in Jefferson County?
450 Gaffney Drive
Seller: Augustine A. Romeo, 1171 Coffeen St., Watertown
Buyer: Kimberly-Scott Creations, LLC, 20350 Staplin Road, Black River
Property: built in 2009, commercial building, sold in April 2009 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $188,800
Price: $260,000 Filed: December 29
702 LeRay Street
Seller: Alicia Hollenbeck, 702 LeRay St., Watertown
Buyer: Richard Rapholz, 14386 CR 75, Adams
Property: built in 1880, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in June 2023 for $95,000
City’s Total Assessment: $69,600
Price: $4,000 Filed: December 29
475 Bugbee Drive
Seller: Shelly A. Fulkerson, William P. Putnam Trust
Buyer: Shelly A. Fulkerson and Randy R. Fulkerson, 475 Bugbee Dr., Watertown
Property: built in 1964, 5 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in April 2022 for $350,000
City’s Total Assessment: $290,000
Price: $0 Filed: December 29
332 Central Street
Seller: Roger A. Hudziak, 332 Central St., Watertown, Doreen R. Collins Estate
Buyer: Dylan T. Atkinson, 426 S. Pleasant St., Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 9 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 1993 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $72,600
Price: $25,000 Filed: December 28
759 Starbuck Avenue
Seller: Michael J. Mitchell, 28251 NYS Route 180, Watertown
Buyer: 1009 Washington, LLC, 759 Starbuck Ave., Suite 1, Watertown
Property: built in 1918, commercial building, sold in Aug. 2007 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $203,300
Price: $1 Filed: December 28
1009 Washington Street
Seller: Catherine D. Mitchell, 28251 NYS Route 180, Watertown
Buyer: 1009 Washington, LLC, 759 Starbuck Ave., Suite 1, Watertown
Property: built in 1910, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2021 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $99,400
Price: $1 Filed: December 28
521 and 527 Waite Avenue
Seller: Penny Luiz, 10101 Lawrence Road, Adams
Buyer: Alvin F. Roe, III, 25867 State Route 12, Watertown
Price: $0 Filed: December 27
715 Griffin Street
Seller: Jacob Raab, 271 Franklin St., Watertown, Mikayla Gagne, North Royalton, OH
Buyer: Peter J. and Kayla Garwood, 1158 Academy St., Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in May 2023 for $129,999
City’s Total Assessment: $77,100
Price: $140,000 Filed: December 26
Prepared by:
631 Bronson Street
Seller: Joseph K. Martusewicz, 65 Spring St., Adams
Buyer: Next Level Property Group, LLC, 9 Bridge St., Carthage
Property: built in 1920, 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold in March 2020 for $25,000
City’s Total Assessment: $50,600
Price: $35,000 Filed: December 26
131 Cedar Street
Seller: Catherine A. Cummings and Kenneth E. Cote III, 131 Cedar St., Watertown
Buyer: Kenney Willie Torres Rodriguez and Andrea Torres, Columbia, SC
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in Aug. 2018 for $137,000
City’s Total Assessment: $121,400
Price: $213,900 Filed: December 22
428 Dimmick Street
Seller: Kristian F. LaVere and Linda J. Johnston LaVere, 428 Dimmick St., Watertown
Buyer: Michael Goodwin, 120 S. Pearl Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in April 2013 for $28,000
City’s Total Assessment: $85,400
Price: $127,000 Filed: December 22
303 N. Indiana Avenue
Seller: Maya R. Bellinger, 303 N. Indiana Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Steve R. and Staphanaika Banks, 26799 Libby Lane, Evans Mills
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in Nov. 2021 for $99,900
City’s Total Assessment: $81,900
Price: $114,000 Filed: December 22
512 Stone Street
Seller: Nuno B. Henriques and Joel S. Ferreira, 924 Peachtree Road, Union, NJ
Buyer: Monument Property Group, LLC, 339 Dodge Ave., Sackets Harbor
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Feb. 2005 for $48,500
City’s Total Assessment: $53,400
Price: $30,000 Filed: December 22
311 William Street
Seller: Aaron P. Quencer and Sandy P. Quencer, Watertown
Buyer: Aladin S. Umar, Sr., 510 Curtis St., Apt. 4, Watertown
Property: built in 1950, sold in March 2011 for $110,000
City’s Total Assessment: $121,400
Price: $253,000 Filed: December 22
442 Flower Avenue East
Seller: SJ Converse Realty, LLC, 17557 Brickstone Loop, Fort Myers, FL
Buyer: John R. Hodge, 8929 State Route 12E, Chaumont
Property: built in 1900, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Feb. 2021 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $26,900
Price: $30,000 Filed: December 21
750 Ball Avenue
Seller: Michael B. and Cindy Braddock, 585-B Conner Rd., West Point, NY
Buyer: Kenneth E. Cote III and Catherine A. Cummings, 131 Cedar St., Watertown
Property: built in 1930, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 2013 for $219,000
City’s Total Assessment: $217,700
Price: $279,900 Filed: December 21
113 Park Drive
Seller: Peter J. Kennedy, 113 Park Dr. E., Watertown
Buyer: William C. Gibson, 2255 Dewey Ave., Rochester
Property: built in 1920, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in July 2021 for $290,000
City’s Total Assessment: $248,100
Price: $340,000 Filed: December 21
109 California Avenue
Seller: Joan Lehrack, 109 California Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Joan Lehrack Irrevocable Trust, John Lehrack, Angela Cherochack
Property: built in 1899, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2001 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $112,600
Price: $0 Filed: December 20
Prepared by:
312 Winslow Street
Seller: Kristina M. Ronson Robinson, 20393 Salter Rd., Watertown
Buyer: Barbosa Real Estate, LLC, 27367 Perch Lake Road, Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in April 2004 for $35,000
City’s Total Assessment: $96,400
Price: $113,000 Filed: December 20
178 Haney Street
Seller: John L. Morris, Jr., Watertown, John L. Morris Estate
Buyer: Matthew Soluri, 112 Court St., Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $56,500
Price: $28,500 Filed: December 19
133 East Main Street
Seller: Virginia Syrotchen, Black River, Mary Smith, Evans Mills, Michael P. Sayers Estate
Buyer: Harrison K Holdings, LLC, 21700 Farney Pit Road, Carthage
Property: built in 1864, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 2003 for $44,000
City’s Total Assessment: $70,900
Price: $1 Filed: December 19
203 Park Drive East
Seller: Gary C. Ashe Estate, Barbara E. Ashe, 19648 CR 65, Watertown
Buyer: Barbara E. Ashe Irrevocable Income Only Trust, Kimberly Sourwine, Gary Ashe
Property: built in 1927, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Feb. 2005 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $172,900
Price: $1 Filed: December 19
203 St. Mary Street
Seller: Arie Shavit, 6011 SE 107th St., Ocala, FL
Buyer: Branden Petersen and Christina Petersen, 17328 Cook Rd., Watertown
Property: built in 1920, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Sept. 2004 for $32,000
City’s Total Assessment: $62,500
Price: $65,000 Filed: December 19
153 Breen Avenue and 25
Seller: David and Diane Roy Family Trust, 204 Breen Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Matthew D. Roy, 715 Eddy St., Watertown
Property: vacant land, sold in April 2020 for $55,000
City’s Total Assessment: $12,400
Price: $1 Filed: December 18
400 Brainard Street
Seller: Stephen J. Harrienger, 17905 CR 66, Sackets Harbor
Buyer: Paul D. Barter, Jr., 1349 Richards Dr., Watertown
Property: built in 1918, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Feb. 1992 for $42,000
City’s Total Assessment: $90,100
Price: $178,000 Filed: December 18
Prepared by:
225 Colorado Avenue
Seller: Nicholas Sherwood, PO Box 6046, Watertown
Buyer: Anthony Levi Clark and Samantha D. Clark, Yelm, Washington
Property: built in 1903, 5 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Jan. 2022 for $87,000
City’s Total Assessment: $111,600
Price: $244,500 Filed: December 18
Prepared by:
406 Stone Street
Seller: Christopher H. and Christina M. Davis, by referee Todd J. Doldo, Esq.
Buyer: Nationstar Mortgage, LLC, MR Cooper
Property: built in 1870, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2000 for $25,000
City’s Total Assessment: $79,500
Price: $97,380 Filed: December 18
835 Water Street
Seller: APN Properties, LLC, 232 Commerce Park Dr., Box 454, Watertown
Buyer: Dane Harris, 14532 Frankton St., Rosedale, NY
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2023 for $44,851
City’s Total Assessment: $64,000
Price: $199,900 Filed: December 15
127 Fairmont Avenue
Seller: Michael E. Carpenter and Mary Jo Carpenter, 14190 Boulder Creek Road, Watertown
Buyer: Carpenter Family Trust
Property: built in 1940, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in May 2012 for $103,000
City’s Total Assessment: $90,300
Price: $0 Filed: December 14
183 Flower Avenue East
Seller: Stephen B. Bolton, 183 Flower Ave. E., Watertown
Buyer: Bolton Legacy Trust
Property: built in 1925, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Feb. 1992 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $87,800
Price: $0 Filed: December 14
1315 Marra Drive
Seller: Gary E. Kocher, Alexandria Bay, and Barry C. Kocher Estate
Buyer: Delaney M. Frears, Sackets Harbor
Property: built in 1960, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Sept. 2021 for $165,000
City’s Total Assessment: $141,000
Price: $215,000 Filed: December 14
1170 Ives Street
Seller: T. Urling Walker Estate, Laurel W. Pike, 22579 E. Gotham St. Rd., Watertown, and Thomas U. Walker Jr., Washington, DC
Buyer: Vishal D. Sudera, 1419 Loomus Dr., Watertown
Property: built in 1966, 7 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2006 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $458,000
Price: $450,000 Filed: December 14
VL-1 Marble Street
Seller: VL-1 Marble Street, 1067 Marble St., Watertown
Buyer: Hales Bus Garage, LLC, 37 Kirkland Ave., Clinton, NY
Property: vacant land, sold in Sept. 2017 for $1,500
City’s Total Assessment: $13,600
Price: $20,000 Filed: December 13
VL-8 Water Street
Seller: Robert C. Freeman, III, 1067 Marble St., Watertown
Buyer: Hales Bus Garage, LLC, 37 Kirkland Ave., Clinton, NY
Property: vacant land, sold in Aug. 2011 for $275,000
City’s Total Assessment: $68,000
Price: $60,000 Filed: December 13
1410 Gill Street and M19
Seller: Glenn A. Kelly, 1410 Gill St., Watertown
Buyer: Glenn A. Kelly Living Trust, 1410 Gill St., Watertown
Property: built in 1881, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $69,100
Price: $0 Filed: December 13
708 Lillian Street and VL
Seller: Jason D. Compo, 10837 Wright Street Road, Adams
Buyer: Alicia M. Stevens, 4854 East Road, Turin
Property: built in 1900, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in May 2013 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $62,300
Price: $92,500 Filed: December 13
322 Waltham Street
Seller: Richard E. and Cindy L. Aldrich, 322 Waltham St., Watertown
Buyer: Upscalehomes NNY, LLC, 1555 State St., Watertown
Property: built in 1870, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in April 1994 for $40,000
City’s Total Assessment: $76,600
Price: $20,000 Filed: December 12
237 Michigan Avenue
Seller: Maureen A. McGuire, 24957 Eastern Blvd., Watertown
Buyer: Nathaniel B. Mullen and Haley A. Kuehn, 729 Gotham St., Apt. A, Watertown
Property: built in 1932, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in March 2021 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $110,800
Price: $183,000 Filed: December 12
426 Coffeen Street
Seller: Kenneth W. Thompson Jr., 426 Coffeen St., Watertown
Buyer: Michael Hebert, 50 Southwest 3rd Ave., #103, Boca Raton, FL
Property: built in 1860, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in July 2018 for $57,000
City’s Total Assessment: $71,600
Price: $105,000 Filed: December 12
807 Bigham Avenue
Seller: Wendell G. Fraser, Raleigh, NC
Buyer: Hui Sun Mooney, PO Box 498, Black River
Property: built in 1880, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $23,600
Price: $15,000 Filed: December 8
681 Burchard Street
Seller: Joseph Murtha II, 100 St. Lawrence Ave. W., Brownville
Buyer: APN Properties, LLC, 232 Commerce Park Dr., Box 454, Watertown
Property: built in 1881, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Sept. 2023 for $17,852
City’s Total Assessment: $86,200
Price: $1 Filed: December 8
159 St. Mary Street
Seller: Jonathan D. Neuschwander, 159 St. Mary St., Watertown
Buyer: Heidi Scott, 36035 Amend Road, LaFargeville
Property: built in 1910, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2019 for $118,000
City’s Total Assessment: $101,700
Price: $179,000 Filed: December 7
129 Katherine Street
Seller: Beth A. Linderman, 927 Ives St., Watertown
Buyer: Clifford K. Pickett Jr. and Carol A. Lyng-Pickett, 20791 Weaver Rd., Watertown
Property: built in 1917, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in July 2005 for $70,000
City’s Total Assessment: $72,200
Price: $125,000 Filed: December 6
1502 Amherst Street and M203
Seller: Thomas R. Young, PO Box 295, Corvallis, MT
Buyer: Kate D. and Michael Harrienger, 24287 CR 67, Watertown
Property: built in 1960, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in March 2022 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $92,100
Price: $60,000 Filed: December 6
180 Duffy Street
Seller: Trey Evan Williams and Megan G. Williams, 180 Duffy St., Watertown
Buyer: Matthew W. Davis, 775 Oswego Ave., Fort Drum
Property: built in 1920, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in June 2021 for $235,000
City’s Total Assessment: $176,200
Price: $227,970 Filed: December 6
1133 Harrison Street
Seller: Travis Hodge and Ashlyn Kate Hodge, 1133 Harrison St., Watertown
Buyer: Michael P. Gil Guerrero and Brenda Noeli Cruz Lopez, 8711 Noble St., Evans Mills
Property: built in 1963, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in April 2020 for $153,000
City’s Total Assessment: $140,200
Price: $229,000 Filed: December 5
623 Mill Street
Seller: Marguerite M. Feistel and Mary A. LaVere, Thelma E. Koelmel Trust, Dexter
Buyer: William A. Koelmel II and Laurie G. Koelmel, 23809 CR 59, Dexter
Property: built in 1880, 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2005 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $104,000
Price: $60,000 Filed: December 5
557 W. Main Street
Seller: Michael Chiappone, 557 W. Main St., Watertown
Buyer: Five Five Seven, LLC, 259 Mullin St., Watertown
Property: built in 1972, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $239,200
Price: $340,000 Filed: December 5
119 Colorado Avenue
Seller: John J. Gaffney, 119 Colorado Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Erin N. Henderson, Bethel Park, PA, and Kevin M. Gaffney, Springdale, AR
Property: built in 1903, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in April 2010 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $116,200
Price: $0 Filed: December 5
154 Winslow Street
Seller: Ferris Holdings, LLC, 142 Arcade St., Suite 101, Watertown
Buyer: Timothy L. Brown, Jr., 15735 Eimicke Place, Apt. 108, Watertown
Property: built in 1826, sold in August 2020 for $156,193
City’s Total Assessment: $115,500
Price: $340,000 Filed: December 5
1341 Ives Street
Seller: Thomas M. Tooker, Carthage, and Shimkonis Family Revocable Living Trust
Buyer: Christopher and Stephanie Goodnough McCarthy, 25569 Plank Rd., Calcium
Property: built in 1971, 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in April 2000 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $195,300
Price: $222,600 Filed: December 5
1444 Holcomb Street
Seller: Travani Construction, LLC, 1634 State St., Watertown
Buyer: Robert Digiacco and Alka Srivastava, 34 Klondike Rd., Ogdensburg
Property: built in 1954, 5 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, sold in Sept. 2022 for $130,000
City’s Total Assessment: $153,500
Price: $580,000 Filed: December 4
318 S. Rutland Street
Seller: Veterans Affairs, Washington, DC
Buyer: Sunrise Horizons, LLC, 36403 Nolan Road, Theresa
Property: built in 1900, 5 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in May 2023 for $10
City’s Total Assessment: $125,600
Price: $78,000 Filed: December 4
541 Water Street
Seller: H&Z Evans Mills, LLC, 923 Emmett St., Watertown
Buyer: Brandon Sinclair, 21557 Heather Acres Dr., Apt. 11B, Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 5 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2017 for $14,900
City’s Total Assessment: $89,100
Price: $226,000 Filed: December 4
122 California Avenue
Seller: Thomas J. Bruton, 122 California Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Michael H. Fraad Jr. and Patricia N. Fraad, 211 Noah Lane, Perry, GA
Property: built in 1910, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2020 for $135,900
City’s Total Assessment: $105,500
Price: $165,500 Filed: December 1
161 Duffy Street
Seller: Bailey Meyer and Elisabeth Paige Meyer, 161 Duffy St., Watertown
Buyer: Peter C. Harris, 26104 Jewett Place, Calcium
Property: built in 1965, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2022 for $200,000
City’s Total Assessment: $134,300
Price: $239,000 Filed: December 1
426, 438 and 432 Arsenal Street
Seller: Steven C. Daily, 426-A Arsenal St., Watertown
Buyer: Philipp Vu, 17804 19th Ave. W., Lynnwood, WA
Price: $210,000 Filed: December 1
